CAD vs Hand Carving: Which Method Suits Your Piece?
CAD modelling builds the piece as a measured 3D file and renders it photorealistically before anything is made; hand carving shapes the piece from wax by eye and by hand. CAD is more accurate and far cheaper to revise, which is why most engagement rings and production runs are modelled. Hand carving suits one-off pieces where the marks of the maker are part of the point. Both end up cast in our Hatton Garden workshop.
| Consideration | CAD modelling | Hand carving |
|---|---|---|
| Accuracy to size | Measured in millimetres; finger size, band width and stone seats are exact | Held by eye; small variation is normal |
| Changing the design | Revised on screen in hours, before any metal is cut | Re-carved, so earlier work is lost |
| Symmetry | Identical on both sides by construction | Depends on the carver’s hand |
| Character of finish | Very clean; needs deliberate work to look hand-made | Slightly irregular, visibly hand-worked |
| Best suited to | Engagement rings, matched pairs, production runs | Single sculptural or figurative pieces |
| Cost driver | Design hours plus the build | Bench hours of carving |
| Typical lead time | Renders within 24 hours of brief; 2-4 weeks overall | Longer design phase, quoted per job |
What is the real difference between CAD and hand carving?
The difference is where the decisions happen. With CAD, every dimensional decision is made on screen, where a mistake costs nothing: you see the depth of the basket, the thickness of the claws and the profile of the shoulder before a single gram of metal is committed. With hand carving, the decisions are made in wax, in the hand, and the only way to change them is to take material off or start again.
That does not make hand carving inferior — a hand-carved piece carries a quality a model struggles to fake. It makes it less forgiving. If your design is not settled, CAD is the cheaper place to find that out.
Which method is more accurate for an engagement ring?
CAD, decisively, wherever a stone has to sit properly. The setting has to match the actual stone: a 1.90ct oval is not the same shape as a 2.00ct oval of the same spread, and the claws have to land on the girdle you actually have. A model lets us measure the stone and cut seats to it before casting, and the same file then instructs the setter.
For a ring that must be a specific finger size, or a pair of wedding bands that have to match, the measured route removes an entire class of remake.
Where does hand carving still win?
Sculptural work, figurative pieces and anything where the surface itself is the design. A carved floral shoulder or a hand-worked organic band reads differently when a person has cut it, and customers who choose that route usually want exactly that. We will say so rather than talk you into a model.
There is also a middle route used constantly in our workshop: model the structure in CAD for accuracy, then finish by hand — engraving, milgrain and polishing — so the piece has both.
Does the method change the price or the timeline?
It changes what drives the price. CAD work is quoted per job and priced on design hours; hand carving is priced on the bench hours of the carver. Neither is automatically cheaper, and for a simple band the difference is small.
Timeline is where CAD usually wins: first renders within 24 hours of an agreed brief, revisions the same working day, then a standard build of 2-4 weeks from approval including setting and UK hallmarking. Hand carving lengthens the front end, which matters if you are working towards a date. Where a date cannot move, our express service compresses a build to 4-6 days, and we will tell you honestly whether your design allows it.
Questions about this
Can you carve a design in CAD and still make it look hand-made?
Yes. The structure is modelled for accuracy and the finish is done by hand — engraving, milgrain and polishing — which is how most of our bespoke pieces are made.
Do I need a CAD file to start a commission?
No. A photograph, a sketch or an existing ring is enough for us to build the model from.
Is a cast CAD ring weaker than a hand-carved one?
Not inherently. Strength comes from the design and the metal, not from the method of making the model. A thin cast band and a thin carved band fail in the same way.
Where this happens
Both routes are the same workshop at 100 Hatton Garden, Suite 225, London EC1N 8NX.
CAD jewellery design at our Hatton Garden workshop